Skip Etsy: How to Create Custom Baby Shower & Bachelorette Gifts for Half the Price

If you’ve started planning a baby shower or bachelorette party, you’ve probably fallen into the same trap as everyone else… You open Etsy, add a few personalised tote bags, maybe some custom glasses… and suddenly your total is €150+
The truth is: You’re not paying for the product, you’re paying for the middleman. But here’s the good news…
You can create the exact same personalised items yourself, for a fraction of the price. And no, you don’t need design skills or a Cricut machine.

How Much You Actually Save

Let’s break it down:
On Etsy:
- Personalised tote bag: €15–€25 each
- Custom mug/glass: €10–€18 each
- Shipping: €10–€20
- For a group of 10? You’re easily spending €150–€250
DIY Method:
-Tote bag via Printify: €6–€10
-Glasses: €5–€8
-No bulk markup
-Total: closer to €60–€100
-That’s literally half the price.

The Easy DIY Method (No Experience Needed)
Here’s how it works:

Step 1: Use a Ready-Made Design

Begin with a template instead of designing from scratch. This is how most sellers create their products, but by doing it yourself, you skip the extra cost. You can use a free template to get started quickly.

I’ve created free editable templates you can grab below.

See free editable templates

Step 2: Edit in Canva

Open the template and personalise it with your event details, such as names, dates, or colours. The platform is very easy to use, and most designs only take a few minutes to customise.

Step 3: Upload to Printify

Upload your design to Printify and choose the product you want, like a tote bag or glass. You’ll instantly see a preview so you can check everything before ordering.

Print on Printify

Step 4: Order & Deliver

Once you’re happy, place your order and let Printify handle printing and shipping. Your items will arrive ready to use, with no extra work needed.

Or you can skip Step 1 and 2 and design from scratch on Printify

Get My FREE Templates (Save Even More)

If you want to skip the design step completely, I’ve put together a free starter pack.

Join Tails and Tiny Toes to get instant access to this template + exclusive baby & party printables.

Want Something More Premium?

If you want more polished, unique designs (the kind that look high-end Etsy level), I’ve also created a collection of ready-to-use templates in my shop.

These include:

  • Matching sets (totes + glasses + signs)
  • Trendy, aesthetic designs
  • Fully customisable in minutes

👉 Browse my templates here

⚠️ Common Mistakes to Avoid

Before you order, avoid these:
  • Uploading low-quality files
  • Not checking product sizing
  • Ordering too late (leave 1–2 weeks)
I walk through all of this in the free guide included with the templates.

Final Thoughts

Etsy is great for inspiration but you don’t need to pay premium prices for something you can easily create yourself. With the right templates and tools, you can:

  • Save €100+
  • Fully personalise everything
  • Still get that Pinterest-perfect look

Grab your FREE templates now and start creating your own custom baby shower or bachelorette gifts today.

Join Tails and Tiny Toes to get instant access to this template + exclusive baby & party printables.
3

Oh hi there 👋
It’s nice to meet you.

Sign up to receive awesome content in your inbox, every month.

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

Scroll to Top